Payroll Supervisor

Company: Crete Professionals Alliance
Location: Tucson
Posted on: April 1, 2026

Job Description:

Cutler Advisors is hiring! Cutler Advisors is an independent, full-service accounting and advisory firm specializing in accounting and consulting services for businesses and individuals. We currently have offices in: Murrysville, PA Scottsdale, AZ Tucson, AZ Join a rapidly growing organization with a strategic vision and dynamic plan. We are seeking an experienced Payroll Supervisor to join our team. The Payroll Supervisor will be an integral part of a small team with the goal of delivering excellent service to our valued clients. We are committed to fostering a supportive and inclusive workplace where every team member can thrive. Apply today to be part of a company that values its people and their contributions! Requirements: Knowledge of tax filings, especially business tax filings Submit payroll tax payments through EFTPS and the states Prepare and communicate payroll filing and payment instructions Prepare and reconcile payroll journals, tax liabilities, tax deposits and any related payroll adjustments Process and update tax changes and deductions Supervise a team of Payroll Specialists Maintain and perform full-service payroll functions for 250 clients Prepare and file monthly, quarterly, and annual payroll reports with the IRS and states Set up EFTPS and state payroll accounts Clear communication with clients and coworkers Proficiency in payroll functions Qualifications: 10 years of related payroll experience strongly preferred Knowledge of multi-state tax laws Knowledge of filing state sales tax returns, and personal property tax filing Strong Computer Skills (Excel, Word) Understanding of Payroll, Finance & Accounting practices Must have strong organizational and communication skills Organizational Awareness Attention to Detail & Problem Solving Excellent Verbal & Written Communication Analytical thinking Integrity Ability to work under pressure and meet required deadlines, work some weekends as necessary Work Remotely No Job Type: Full-time Pay: $75K - $90K annually Schedule: 8-hour shift Work Location: In person This position operates in Tucson, AZ with typical working hours aligning with Mountain Standard Time (MST) zone to facilitate effective collaboration. We offer flexibility in managing your schedule to maintain a healthy work-life balance while meeting business needs. We are excited to invite talented individuals to join our dynamic team! This position offers a competitive rate between $75K – $90K per year, commensurate with experience and qualifications. In addition to a rewarding career, we provide a robust benefits package, including: Health, Dental, and Vision Insurance (with options for fully paid employee only coverage for health and dental) Company-Paid Life and Long-Term Disability Insurance Ancillary Benefits such as supplemental life insurance and short-term disability options Classic Safe Harbor 401(k) Plan with employer contributions Opportunities for professional growth, learning, and development including access to Becker and LinkedIn Learning "David Cutler Accountants Advisors", an independent member of the Crete Professionals Alliance, is the brand name under which David S. Cutler, CPA, PC and David S. Cutler, CPA, PLLC (collectively referred to as “DSC CPA”) and Cutler Advisors LLC d/b/a David S. Cutler Advisors (“Advisors”) provide professional services. DSC CPA and Advisors practice as an alternative practice structure in accordance with the AICPA Code of Professional Conduct and applicable laws, regulations, and professional standards. DSC CPA is a licensed independent CPA firm that provides attest services to its clients, and Advisors provides tax and business consulting services to their clients. Advisors and Crete Professionals Alliance are not licensed CPA firms. The entities falling under the David Cutler Accountants Advisors brand are independently owned and are not liable for the services provided by any other entity providing the services under the David Cutler Accountants Advisors brand. Our use of the terms “our firm” and “we” and “us” and terms of similar import, denote the alternative practice structure conducted by DSC CPA and Advisors. Crete Professionals Alliance is an equal opportunity employer, considering all applicants for employment regardless of race, color, religion, sex, gender identity, pregnancy, national origin, ancestry, citizenship, age, marital status, physical disability, sexual orientation, genetic information, or any other characteristic protected by state of federal law. LI-BP1

Keywords: Crete Professionals Alliance, Catalina Foothills , Payroll Supervisor, Accounting, Auditing , Tucson, Arizona